meluvjonas Says:

Jun 27, 2008 - i cry when i hear this song..... <3 it!

MichaelinDenmark Says:

Jul 2, 2008 - LMAO - you are funny. Who gives a shit about your comment - WE THE FANS KNOW THE TRUTH

charomiami Says:

Jul 2, 2008 - im a george michael fan, but I gotta say she was brilliant, very nice

oashpe Says:

Jul 3, 2008 - She has an awful voice she is not worth the song of George Michael

jaymejean28 Says:

Jul 7, 2008 - um you're deaf

krb1927 Says:

Jul 8, 2008 - Carrie did a WONDERFUL job with this George Michael classic. She could have sang ANY number of songs that night but SHE chose this one because it was appropriate for the charity event and also because she has always been a fan of George Michael. Thanks to Carrie, millions of young people heard this song for the first time and were also treated to a live performance by George Michael a few weeks later. This would not have happened if Carrie had not selected this song to perform.

byteme2008 Says:

Jul 8, 2008 - most performed their new hits on the show and she just had released her album yet she didn't do that. Mariah did, Miley did......Carrie didn't and introduced me to this song.

hedunlap Says:

Jul 11, 2008 - You must be talking about your mom.

oashpe Says:

Jul 13, 2008 - why not singing her own songs instead of singing the songs of others ? there is no creativity at all involved besides her voice does not fit georges michael's song it's crap !

byteme2008 Says:

Jul 13, 2008 - because this was for charity so she didn't pimp her own NEW album. She put that aside unlike most others that performed like mariah or miley

krb1927 Says:

Jul 15, 2008 - You know, I went and listened to George's performance from the American Idol Finale. Of course, he did an excellent job...he has a great voice!! But, what was even more astonishing was that there was no "bashing" from Carrie Underwood fans. Maybe YOU George Michael fans should take some lessons on manners from Carrie's fans...they have "class" just like Carrie.

CountryGiirl3 Says:

Jul 20, 2008 - This is just amazing. She has such a powerful voice. Carrie Underwood is the best. Beats George Micheal! :D

4theluvofmusic14 Says:

Jul 24, 2008 - i thank his version was good when he sang but she had more emotion when she sang it. i could really understand where she was coming from and i wanted to hear more. When he sang a couple weeks later it just wasn't the same. i was very disappointed with the lack of emotion.

perlonu777 Says:

Jul 26, 2008 - My goodness she is such a great talent. She has such a beautiful voice and I'm so happy American Idol discovered her!

dfwguy1960 Says:

Jul 27, 2008 - she really butchered that one

byteme2008 Says:

Jul 27, 2008 - you're fucking deaf it appears. I guess the 5 star ratings and all of the great comments opposite of your view prove it, minority table one!

hsmla Says:

Jul 28, 2008 - amen dude

hsmla Says:

Jul 28, 2008 - u suck

pochie64 Says:

Jul 31, 2008 - Your an idiot!! dfguy1960. Do you saw all the people at the end gave her standing ovation. That prove that she is one of the best of this new generation of performers.

JennyLynne1994 Says:

Aug 3, 2008 - can you sing?! probably not! so unless you can sing it better then she did you have no room to speak!

JennyLynne1994 Says:

Aug 3, 2008 - I agree. she has a heart, unlike all the other people who are just performing for money.... she sang becuse she cared, and you can tell by the emotion that was in her voice... she is very very good.

hotmasked1 Says:

Aug 3, 2008 - You have to understand that George is older and is singing the song simply in a much lighter note. its nice to hear the song in a different style or manner. Who wants to hear the record version all the time? Carrie did a good job but no one can sing a songs like George listen to all his other live performances and hear it for yourself

StAndrew65 Says:

Aug 4, 2008 - Forget about his voice.... what's up with George Michael's face!?!? It lookes like he just had a chemical peel or some other proceedure that was botched up!!! No wonder he's wearing those horrible sunglasses! Vanity certainly can get you in trouble.... or in his case, in an ugly mess!

girlculture Says:

Aug 13, 2008 - Whew! What can I say? Carrie, you're superb! Good voice quality despite singing in a tight gown while sitting down. That's difficult! I tried it and I cant belt a song out. You Rock!

USA8869 Says:

Aug 20, 2008 - Absolutely beautiful rendition!! She really has some pipes on her! I'm beyond impressed.....