Ashura

salafees Says:

Apr 29, 2008 - Mutah is temporary and so it is like prostitution. Instead, Misyar is permanent and is therefore a marriage. So this is the fundamental and monumental difference between Mutah and Misyar. In Mutah, a Shia man pays a few dollars to have sex with a whore, and they are "married" for less than one hour. On the other hand, Misyar is permanent and lasts forever. In fact, it is Haram to contract Misyar if you have the intention of divorce.

salafees Says:

Apr 29, 2008 - cONT So it is the same as Nikah (i.e. it is Haram to have intention to divorce when you marry that person). So what is Misyar? Misyar is simply when woman voids her right to be financially supported by her husband. This makes common sense: how many of university students today can relate to this? man is still in university & can therefore not support a girl financially. Instead of getting into a life of sin, two get married & woman voids her right to maintenance so that they can get married

salafees Says:

Apr 29, 2008 - cONT1 That is all. That is it. Nothing at all similar to Mutah. Mutah = temporary = prostitution Misyar = permanent = marriage This craze to equate Mutah with Misyar is one of the desperate attempts of the Shia propagandists to conflate simple issues, just like they conflate abrogation with Tahreef. This is to hide their embarrassment over their filthy religion which allows women to be rented by the hour.

salafees Says:

Apr 29, 2008 - Another major difference between Misyar and Mutah is that the Sunni scholars have stated that Misyar is discouraged whereas the Shia scholars actively encourage Mutah, claiming that a woman who whores herself out in Mutah to two men will be forgiven all her sins and enter Paradise. Once again, there is absolutely no comparison between Misyar (which is permanent) to Mutah (which is temporary and can last for even one hour or one day).

salafees Says:

Apr 29, 2008 - cONT2 Another major difference between Misyar and Mutah is that the Sunni scholars have stated that Misyar is discouraged whereas the Shia scholars actively encourage Mutah, claiming that a woman who whores herself out in Mutah to two men will be forgiven all her sins and enter Paradise. Once again, there is absolutely no comparison between Misyar (which is permanent) to Mutah (which is temporary and can last for even one hour or one day).

courseworkdue Says:

Apr 29, 2008 - A woman who whores herself out goes to heaven? Bring proof of shia scholars. Im talking marjae not some clown on the internet. Please dont talk to me about filthy religions or 'authentic' hadiths from you whose "sahih" books accuse the Prophet (saw) of Paedophilia, Murdering Asma the poetess, and of being 'corrected' by the sahaba when his son died as a baby. Your Books arent worth the paper written on. And the point of Mutah was not for fun, it was abused...

courseworkdue Says:

Apr 29, 2008 - It was meant to be for those at the war front who didnt want to go into Zina, and in the modern day is for those who cant afford to get married cos of being students or unemployed, who dont want to do Zina. It is meant to lead to real marriage. Mutah is abused by guys who sleep around but the point was not that

courseworkdue Says:

Apr 29, 2008 - YES or No, a man can have a different wife in every town, doesnt live with her, doesnt give her the equal time as other real wifes. Mistress buddy. It may be a full time mistress but its a mistress

courseworkdue Says:

Apr 29, 2008 - Anyway im more interested in your claim of HAZRAT muawayward. You didnt answer that post. Your beloved slandered Ali (as) to the extent people thought he was a kafir who didnt pray. AstaghfurAllah. Then you bring me something from Nahjul Balaga which only proves Ali's (as) great personality as your proof? pathetic.

lovefobia Says:

Jun 3, 2008 - i want to prove for those who says mutah is haram by omar himself omar said 2 mutah was on the days of rasul mutah of women and mutah el haj , and i deny them and punish for doing them

lovefobia Says:

Jun 3, 2008 - متعتان كانتا على عهد رسول الله وأنا أنهى عنهما وأعاقب عليهما ، متعة الحجّ ومتعة النّساء » (1) .

lovefobia Says:

Jun 3, 2008 - وهذا مسند الإمام أحمد بن حنبل خير شاهد على أنّ أهل السنّة والجماعة مختلفون في هذه المسألة إختلافاً كبيراً فمنهم من يتبع قول الرسول فيحللّها ، ومنهم من يتبع قول عمر بن الخطاب فيحرمه ، أخرج الإمام أحمد : ـ عن إبن عباس قال : تمتع النبي صلّى الله عليه وآله وسلّم ، فقال عروة إبن الزبير : نهى أبو بكر وعمر عن المتعة ، فقال إبن عباس : مايقول عُرية ؟ « تصغير لعروة » قال : يقول نهى أبو أبو بكر وعمر عن المتعة ، فقال إبن عبّاس : أراهم سيهلكون أقول : قال النبي ويقولون نهى أبو بكر وعمر (2) .

lovefobia Says:

Jun 3, 2008 - وجاء في صحيح الترمذي إن عبدالله بن عمر سُئلَ عن متعة الحجّ ، قال : هي حلال . فقال له السائل إن أباك قد نهى عنها . فقال : أرأيت إن كان أبي نهى عنها وصنعها رسول الله أأمر أبي أتبع أم أمر رسول الله ؟ فقال الرجل : بل أمر رسول الله صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم (3) . وأهل السنّة والجماعة أطاعوا عمر في متعة النساء وخالفوه في متعة الحج ـ على أن النهي عنهما وقع منه في موقف واحد كما قدمنا .

lovefobia Says:

Jun 3, 2008 - والمهم في كل هذا إن الآئمة من أهل البيت وشيعتهم خالفوه وأنكروا عليه وقالوا بحلّيتها إلى يوم القيامة .وهناك من علماء أهل السنّة والجماعة في ذلك أيضاً وأذكر من بينهم عالم تونس الجليل وزعيم الجامع الزيتوني فضيلة الشيخ الطاهر بن عاشور رحمة الله عليه ، فقد قال بحلّيتها في تفسيره المشهور عند ذكره آية فما إستمتعتم به منهن فآتوهن أجورهن فريضة (4) .

lovefobia Says:

Jun 3, 2008 - (1) التفسير الكبير للفخر الرّازي في تفسير قوله تعالى فما إستمتعتم به منهن . (2) مسند الإمام أحمد بن حنبل 1 /337 . (3) صحيح الترمذي 1 /157 . (4) التحرير والتنوير للطاهر بن عاشور 3 /5 .

lovefobia Says:

Jun 3, 2008 - عن مسدد حدثنا يحيى عن عمر إن أبي بكر حدثنا أبو رجاء عن عمران بن حصين رضي الله تعالى عنه قال : نزلت آية المتعة في كتاب الله ففعلنا مع رسول الله صلّى الله عليه وآله وسلم ولم ينزل قرآنٌ يحرمه ولم ينه عنها حتى مات قال رجل برأيه ماشاء قال محمد يقال أنه عمر. صحيح البخاري 5 /158 .

lovefobia Says:

Jun 3, 2008 - its in ur books before u claim its in our book even shekh kardawy he didnt find it 7aram

shussein Says:

Aug 6, 2008 - urself dude

shussein Says:

Aug 6, 2008 - same goes to u :)

lailashreen Says:

Aug 29, 2008 - mutah can release women after a temporary marraige and women can be free after tht unlike misyar who tht women will be forever under a men tht only maybe come a year who when only passs the town then have sex with her then go back to his real wife which is not fair at all and it will waste the whole life of tht women and the women children who have to live with out father beside mutah is not for fun only those who really need it and the women have the full right to take money as bride

yusafali Says:

Sep 8, 2008 - why you guys killing my sunni brothers aiding and abetting the ocupation.

hanonah1115 Says:

Sep 28, 2008 - lol us? what about u salafi? go do ur dance and walk on fire and what ev er else u morans do.. u have no brothers u ppl are retards..

zanzune Says:

Oct 4, 2008 - this is narrated by shia 'AND' sunni scholars. The holy prophet muhammad (PBUH): 'I am the city of knowledge and ali is its gate'. This does not mean that Ali has a greater status that the prophet it means that Ali (as)was the heir to the prophet's knowledge.

hanonah1115 Says:

Oct 5, 2008 - y dont u ppl go purify urselves and stop trying to say one is kafir anad one is not.. im sure everyones path to allah swt is strayed.. stop worried for others.. coz in judgment day what will ur answers will be when u r asked y u made fitnah gossip and problems between the believers .. ya hussain ya ahia let us purify ourselves and not be as others who condem and life is haram.. we r the shia of ali.. let us live like ali and die like hussain!

kammezh Says:

Oct 11, 2008 - Ya Rayi can you give a link to a website i can download this audio files cuz i would like to put them on my Mp3 Choukran